A professional roofing contractor should be able to explain the work in writing: what will be inspected, what will be installed, what is excluded, and who is responsible when something goes wrong. MQ Roofing is based in Tomah, WI, has been in business since 2008, and installs shingle, slate, and metal roofing, including standing seam metal, for homeowners across its Wisconsin service area. This guide shows how to compare contractors and written scopes so the bids you collect can actually be measured against each other.
Hiring a roofer is rarely a price-only decision. Two proposals may differ considerably because they describe different work, not merely because one company charges less. The goal is to make every bid answer the same questions first, then compare cost.
Benefits of Hiring a Professional Roofing Contractor

Residential roofing involves heights, weather exposure and layered materials that have to work together. A professional contractor brings several practical advantages:
- Material and system knowledge: A roofer can explain which shingle, slate, or metal option suits your roof shape, slope, and budget, and what the underlayment, flashing, and ventilation should be.
- Safety: Work at height and on steep or wet surfaces is hazardous. Ask how a crew protects workers and your property.
- Insurance and paperwork: Ask what insurance a contractor carries and request documentation, so you are not relying on a verbal answer.
- Fewer repeat repairs: Flashing, deck repairs, and fastening details done correctly the first time reduce the chance of callbacks.
- Schedule and cleanup: A contractor with a clear process can tell you how long tear-off takes, how the property is protected, and how debris is handled.
What Affects the Cost of Hiring a Roofing Contractor

Cost depends on the job in front of the roofer, so ask each company to show how its number was built. The main factors are:
- Roof size and complexity: Larger roofs, steep slopes, many valleys, dormers, and penetrations take more time and material.
- Material selection: Asphalt shingles, slate, and metal differ in material cost and installation method. Standing seam metal involves different panels, trim, and fastening than a shingle roof.
- Roof condition: Rotted decking, past leaks, or poor ventilation can add work that is only visible after the old roof is removed.
- Access and site conditions: Tight driveways, landscaping, outbuildings, and nearby structures change how the crew stages materials and protects the property.
- Scope of related work: Gutters, skylights, flashing replacement, and ventilation upgrades may or may not be in the quote.
A very low bid is not automatically a good deal, and a high bid is not automatically better work. What matters is whether the price covers a complete scope you can describe in your own words.
Side-by-Side Bid Review Checklist
Put each proposal next to the others and fill in the same rows. Blanks are the most useful information, because they show what a contractor has not committed to.
| Item to compare | What a clear proposal states | Follow-up question if it is missing |
|---|---|---|
| Services and scope | Repair, replacement, or new installation, with the roof areas covered | Which parts of the roof, and which related items, are included? |
| Investigation | What was inspected and how, including attic or deck review where applicable | What did you look at before pricing this? |
| Material and system | Named roofing product, underlayment, flashing, and ventilation approach | What exact products and components will be installed? |
| Exclusions | Work not covered, such as hidden deck repair, gutters, or skylight work | What is not in this price, and how are extras approved? |
| Scheduling | Expected start, duration, and a weather plan | What happens if weather interrupts the work? |
| Property protection | How landscaping, siding, driveways, and an occupied home are protected | How will you protect the house, yard, and our daily routine? |
| References and paperwork | Insurance documentation and references you can contact | Can you provide insurance paperwork and references? |
| Warranty responsibility | Who covers workmanship and who covers the manufacturer’s product terms, in writing | What is covered, by whom, and for how long? |
Questions That Reveal Bids You Cannot Compare
If two proposals will not line up row by row, ask the same follow-up questions of each contractor. These tend to expose the gaps:
- What happens to the old roofing and underlayment, and is tear-off included?
- How will damaged decking be priced if it is found after tear-off?
- Will flashing around chimneys, vents, and walls be replaced or reused?
- Is the quote based on a measured roof, or on an estimate from the ground?
- Who is the on-site point of contact, and who is responsible for the final walkthrough?
Confirm any licensing or registration requirements that apply to your project with the state or your city, and ask what each contractor can provide. A bid that cannot answer these questions is not necessarily dishonest, but it is not yet comparable.
Workmanship Warranty Versus Manufacturer Warranty
These are different promises from different parties. A manufacturer warranty applies to the covered roofing product or assembly under its written terms and conditions. A workmanship warranty, if offered, addresses specified installation work under the contractor’s stated terms. Ask what coverage is offered, review the actual documents and exclusions, and retain the paperwork with your final invoice.
Choosing a Residential Roofing Contractor
When evaluating a local contractor, ask about response procedures after installation, familiarity with regional weather and how service concerns are handled. For home projects, you can also read how MQ Roofing approaches asphalt shingle replacement, plan your project with the guide to roof installation preparation and final acceptance, or read about roof installation in Tomah. If storm damage is involved, the roof insurance claim guide explains how claims support fits into the process. To talk through your roof, call MQ Roofing in Tomah, WI at (608) 553-3300.
Frequently Asked Questions
What should I ask a roofing contractor before signing?
Ask for a written scope, the named materials, exclusions, schedule, property protection plan, insurance paperwork, references, and warranty terms.
Why are roofing bids so different in price?
Bids often cover different scopes, materials, and assumptions about hidden damage. Comparing them row by row shows whether the work is the same.
How do workmanship and manufacturer warranties differ?
Workmanship and manufacturer warranties can have different providers, limits and exclusions. Request the actual terms in writing.
Does MQ Roofing install more than one roofing material?
Yes. MQ Roofing installs shingle, slate, and metal roofing, including standing seam metal, and also offers insurance claims support.
